Category Archives: Architecture

Demolition attempt at art

This building has been vacated and will be torn down soon. What are the developers doing in the meantime? (Hint, look at the lit up windows). It would be cool if they could sponsor my favourite small theatre company from the UK to hold a performance here before tearing it down.

And, invite all the residents of Wan Chai and beyond to commemorate the loss of a yet another architectural icon in a truly special manner. By remembering it through an experience and a story.

Advertisements

Abuse of subsidized space

This recent article “Management of the city’s public markets must be improved” -about the abuse of subsidized space- made me think about a quiet corner in Wan Chai market.

It’s quiet because there’s not much economic activity going on there. The stalls nearby must have a love-hate relationship with the two stalls that are perpetually covered up, full of cartons and crates.

On one hand, it’s not competition, so that’s a plus. Maybe they get to store boxes beside those stalls, also a plus. But then again the crowd doesn’t get drawn in. That’s a negative. So those stalls need to build up their business with regulars and the stumble-uponers, that is, the people who just happen to pass by en route elsewhere.

I’ve seen the representatives of the government landlord come round, handing out their papers near the end of the year, the stall owners heaving a sigh at the increase in rent. They are probably thinking of how to handle the questions from clients about the increase in prices for all the produce while everyone adjusts to the inflation while accepting that salary increases are almost negligible.

Renting a stall in the indoor market costs around ten thousand Hong Kong dollars for about 30-40 square feet of space. That’s not cheap for a very basic layout in a rather cramped environment. On the upside, the stalls get fantastic foot traffic from a very mixed crowd. The army of domestic helpers wearing their caps and dragging their trolleys, all jostling for a stall position. The tai tai grandmas who choose to peruse the chaos and when the opportunity arises, shove themselves to the front while loudly complaining how crowded it is to the fishmonger.

The army of MPVs with drivers waiting for their owners gives you a big clue as to the patrons of the various stalls. Wouldn’t a stall owner from outdoors prefer an indoor space? The clients sure do if it’s hot or raining… they already cause major traffic congestion by double parking.

Another example of an abuse of subsidized space must be the Blue House. The renovation of the usable space and it’s tenants has been rather disappointing.

Firstly, the commercial areas.

1) There is no one using the chinese clinic space. Is this space just for show? They should offer a group of bone-setting chinese physicians to use the space. Wouldn’t it be so cool to have a rotating number of chinese docs doing acupressure for clients or even the community? Great PR.

2) The House of Stories is nice and the curator and the young lady docent do their best to promote the history through talks and activities but it’s plain disappointing that you can’t also tour the living quarters of the Blue House. I mean…what did they do in that multimillion dollar renovation?! It would’ve been really fantastic if Hong Kong could pull off a reality museum where you could see what it was like before in photos and what it is now (maybe similar!). That would’ve won some awards and should’ve been a pre-condition to the tenants.

3) The chinese dessert shop is not nicely designed. It’s a pity that they couldn’t learn a design trick or two from Samsen (which manages to replicate the atmosphere of a Thai diner).

4) The organic goods shop is a real mish-mash of random dried and fresh produce. I’m not really sure who they supply. There is a market around the corner y’know.

5) The St. James donation shop is always a fun browse, it’s a whole flea market by itself. But why is the ventilation so poor? There’s a great book collection in there and they should do a proper job making it into a children’s resource or relaxation library… instead it smells like most of the books are being consumed by damp fungi.

Well past 11am on a weekday and it’s closed.

6) The other Hong Kong House of stories room (which is rarely open) should have been amalgamated with the other room to make it a more spacious usable area. The local crafts workshops should run more regularly. It’s a real shame that local artists who regularly paint or photograph in the area can’t exhibit their works more often.

7) The vegetarian restaurant which barely has 4 tables is shoved into a lonesome back area that reminds you of where the bin lockers should be in any building. It’s an afterthought and the menu has no appeal at all. For a similar price, you can have a set lunch comfortably at Green Common or at the OVO restaurant, all within 3-5 minutes walk.

Not big, not small. And not very nice.
Struggling grass… not enough light, soon to be trampled..

8) The small field or lawn should be landscaped more pleasantly. Right now it’s just looks like a disused plot and very attractive to breeding mosquitoes. Lots of photographers and models come to pose at the Blue House. If this could be set up as a nice garden -(yes, with real flowers and plants) for wedding / magazine photos -that would certainly add some sentimental and social value. Lee Tung Avenue’s wedding industry has all but disappeared due to the change in tastes and trends. It would be just fantastic if the Blue House could claw some of that back as part of the storytelling mission.

Taking photos at Lee Tung Avenue would be nice but look no different than photos taken in the Venetian (Macau) or Bicester village. But the Blue House would be unmistakably and definitively Wan Chai.

The mandate of the Blue House should be changed after a study of 2 years and updated. Conservation and preservation should work hand in hand with real education if not for entertainment. I’d like to see St James put in a nice kids area, for reading, for party rental, performances, community gatherings that bring the younger generation in. Kids in urban areas lack good affordable facilities to play in. Those playgrounds nearby are barely good for 10-15 minutes at the most.

Right now, the most famous thing about it is the photo spot next to the supposed chinese docs clinic and a wooden chair right outside the HK House of Stories which invites most people to post that pic on social media to say they’ve been. I just think that after all the effort of Pokemon getting all sorts of people to hang around outside the door of the Blue House catching poke monsters, that there is no other way to really draw them in.

Ps. have you noticed that it’s always the same cars parked in the same place on the street right beside the Blue House? They are pretty much fixtures there. Whoever owns those vehicles is most certainly abusing public space.

Could Wanchai have a beach?

Imagine this – a wonderful article from an urban landscape planning firm– about the development of Wanchai waterfront area to potentially include a green tower and a beach.

“Green tower” left, beach with clean water by 10design

It wouldn’t be a very large beach, probably less than 100 meters length but having a beach with clean water in one of the busiest harbours in the world would be a marvellous sight to see.

This is what it looks like through my lens with some super imposition. The beach and building would be taking the Fenwick Pier site in front of the HKAPA.

The architect’s office is directly behind the proposed site. Perhaps they are sick of looking at the massive construction site and trying hard to envisage a “park” which isn’t a token concrete pavement with some spindly trees alongside.

View of waterfront, Central to Wanchai

Of course it’ll never get built. It’ll be too expensive to maintain those filters, run over budget and infuriate the local cartel of property developers.

Map of Wanchai waterfront

But a beach in Wanchai? That’s just such an awesome idea. Zouk out would finally have a proper location to throw their beach foam party. Families would be able to have play dates in Central. Lovers could congregate and picnic under the stars after a romantic ride on the star ferry. Convention goers would have a proper place for R&R…

Wanchai pros and cons

Drinking venues, Night clubs & Performing Arts ✅

Cool coffee shops & restaurants ✅

Convention Center ✅

MTR station ✅

Trams ✅

Bus stops to all parts of HK ✅

Hardware & Stationery shops ✅

Supermarkets & Street markets ✅

Historic conserved sites ✅

Beach ❌

Clean Air ❌

Low noise & light pollution ❌

Peace & Quiet 🔊⁉️